Demolition approval process may change

The process for demolition approval could change after several members of the Architectural Commission voiced frustration and confusion with the system.

Commissioners and town staff held a lengthy conversation about the topic at Thursdays meeting, and staff members agreed to re-evaluate the process.

The discussion started when commissioners at first denied architect Patrick Segraves application to demolish a bungalow-style house at 310 Australian Ave. because they thought the cottage had historical significance and might be worthy of landmark designation. The commission later granted Segraves approval, but did so reluctantly.

This house wasnt landmarked? member Richard Sammons asked. I think its a significant house. Its a positive contributor to the street, considering that its grouped with other very similar houses. Its a nice old reminder of Old Palm Beach. I hate to see it go.

Other members agreed.

I bemoan the proposed destruction of part of a set that I think are important parts of the whole feeling of the historic part of town, said chairman Robert Vila.

But the house is not landmarked and not on the landmark consideration list, and therefore the commission has no grounds to deny a demolition request, according to town staff.

We have unfortunately run into this rather sad situation in the past, said John Page, Planning, Zoning & Building director. I understand your reluctance to approve demolition for a structure that has some historic value to the community and that you think should be saved, but if the property is not landmarked there is not a lot of discretion from this board to deny a demolition request. The fact that you think its historic or quaint or that is should be preserved is not a valid reason.

Sammons said theres a problem with the process when commissioners think a property should be examined by landmarks, but it isnt on the consideration list. The problem were having with this is were asked to approve the demolition of something thats never been given a hearing by Landmarks.

Landmarks Preservation Commission Chairman Ted Cooney said the commission has to prioritize projects based on its workload and budgetary and staff limitations.

Follow this link:
Demolition approval process may change