Health Law
By Emilie Le Beau Lucchesi
May 21, 2020, 8:00 am CDT
In the autumn of 2014, Brittany Maynard was dying from brain cancer at age 28. Her final weeks were filled with pain, the inability to sleep and frequent seizures, says her husband, Dan Diaz.
Maynards final weeks also included the discussion as to when she would take a lethal prescription that would push her into a deep sleepand then end her life. Maynard had received the prescription legally in Oregon, which allows terminal patients to seek a life-ending prescription from a medical doctor, Diaz says.
About 21% of Americans now live in a state that allows medical aid in dying. Eight states and the District of Columbia have death with dignity laws, also called medical aid in dying laws. These states include California, Colorado, Hawaii, Maine, New Jersey, Oregon, Vermont and Washington, according to Compassion & Choices, an advocacy group.
Although these states allow medical aid in dying, the state laws have specific restrictions about when and how a patient can take the prescription. Advocates for medical aid in dying laws are pushing to ease criteria, so that more patients have access and more providers can offer support.
There are barriers to access, such as a waiting period between formal requests. In some states, patients must wait 15 days between each request and repeat the process with multiple physicians. Advocates argue that not all terminal patients can survive the waiting period.
Another access issue relates to how the medication must be consumed. All states that permit medical aid in dying require the patient to self-ingest the medication and be mentally competent at the time the prescription is taken. That means patients have to make decisions as to when they will take the prescription, so they can remain within the perimeters of the law.
For example, a patient with Lou Gehrigs disease, or amyotrophic lateral sclerosis, could eventually lose the ability to swallow. The patient would have to discuss their progression with their physician or hospice nurse. But, some religious organizations forbid their employees from having end-of-life discussions or from being present when the prescription is consumed.
For Maynard, she worried an incapacitating stroke would render her unable to self-ingest the medication. In her final weeks, Maynard experienced violent seizures on a daily basis, Diaz says.
It comes to the point, are you living in those days? Or only suffering through them? Diaz asks.
That was when Brittany said, This is my time. Ive lived a good life. Her fear was that what would come next for her was a stroke. She could lose her ability to communicate altogether. Lose her ability to swallow. She said, There is no way I will die like that, trapped in my own body.
When Maynard was first diagnosed, she was living in California. The state had not yet passed the End of Life Option Act, and Maynard wanted the option.
We had to pack up half our house in a U-Haul, say goodbye to family and friends and drive up to Oregon, Diaz says.
In Oregon, Maynard and Diaz rented a house and found a medical care team associated with a university hospital. Maynard obtained residency and entered clinical trials.As her disease progressed, Maynard also obtained the lethal prescription and planned to take it before she lost her ability to swallow or communicate.
Currently, state laws require patients to be sound of mind both when the prescription is requested and taken. Physicians are tasked with ensuring patients meet all the criteria at the time the prescription is written.
Those roles are spelled specifically. [Physicians] must assess the prognosis, diagnosis, patients state of mind, mental capacity, they must advise the patient of all options of end-of-life care, says Barbara Coombs Lee, an attorney and former nurse in Portland who helped draft the Oregon law.
Euthanasia, which is illegal in the United States, involves when someone other than the patient administers medication in any form with the intention of hastening the patients death, according to the American Nursing Association. For example, Vermonts Patient Choice at the End of Life Act states that the law shall not be construed for any purpose to constitute suicide, assisted suicide, mercy killing, or homicide.
The state laws additionally require the patient to receive the prescription from a medical doctor who is licensed to diagnose and treat the underlying condition. The doctor must be the same physician overseeing the patients care.
You cant go to ophthalmologist or dermatologist for your lung cancer, Lee says.
Once the prescription is obtained, the patient stores it at home and may choose when to take it. Diaz says his wife was prescribed secobarbital.The powder comes in about 100 capsules that the patient must open and mix into water.He says the process takes about 40 minutes.
Some laws permit others to help the patient open and mix the powder. In Vermont, for example, the law permits assistance with preparation if the patient is not considered exposed to grave harm, which means that witnesses to the death have no liability.
Advocates argue the laws protect the professionals right of refusal, but not their right to support. Lee says that when she and others wrote the Oregon bill, they intentionally protected medical care providers right of refusal.
At the time, she says, they did not realize that religious-based hospitals and hospices would forbid employees from having end-of-life discussions, writing the prescription or supporting the patient in their final moments. Most patients who use medical aid in dying are in at-home hospice care, and many have the same nurse who visits each day. Hospices can block nurses from being with their patient when the prescription is ingested, which can be upsetting for the patient, their families and the nurses.
We never intended that an institution could hold patients hostage to its doctrinal rules and beliefs, Lee says. Doctors should be allowed to serve their patients requests off premises and off the clock of a refusing facility.
The American Medical Association officially opposes medical aid in dying. But in 2019, the American Nurses Association changed its position statement to address growing conflicts between nurses and their employers. Whereas the 2013 statement had prohibited nurses from participating in medical aid in dying, the new statement called for nurses to be knowledgeable and objective, and for hospices and hospitals to clarify how a nurse can proceed if asked to support a patient.
The change in the position statement happened because we were receiving inquiries from nurses, hospital leaders, and wondered, what does it mean to participate? One of the main issues is, can the nurse even be in the room? says Liz Stokes, the director of the AmericanNurses Association Center for Ethics and Human Rights.
Religious organizations typically forbid nurses from being in the patients home when the prescription is taken. Other organizations have vague rules that imply the nurse should step away from the room while the patient swallows the prescription but can return to support the family. Stokes says the ANA wants greater clarification so that nurses who want to support their patients understand their employers perimeters.
The presence of a nurse during the process can be both comforting and helpful to the patient and their families. Stokes says that patients often experience nausea, and a nurse is permitted to administer anti-nausea medications. Nurses can also help explain the process as the patient drifts into a sleep, and then slowly stops breathing.
For Maynard, her palliative care team was not with her when she took her prescription. Diaz says one of their friends who was present was a physician, which was a great source of comfort.
Although nurses and physicians have legal protections to refuse discussing or participating in medical aid in dying, some opponents want to go a step further and seek to overturn state laws. In New Jersey, physician Yosef Glassman sued the states attorney general to stop a new law, which he described as a violation of his religious tenets.
As a geriatrician, Glassman is a general practitioner for the older population. Not a specialist, he is not legally allowed to write a lethal prescription. If one of his patients, however, is dying from a terminal illness such as cancer, the oncologist might ask Glassman to transfer the patients file.
It is the act of sharing the file that Glassman opposes. Glassman sued the state to prevent even the possibility of his secondary involvement in medical Aid in dying in advance of the law going into effect.
In the filed complaint, his attorney, E. David Smith, argued the responsibility of sharing a file goes against Glassmans First Amendment right to practice his religion, Orthodox Judaism, that holds all human life is sacred and must not be taken.
My client feels very strongly that no doctor has a right to determine that is a life no longer [worth] living, says Smith.
Glassman initially succeeded in stopping the state law before it took effect. In August 2019, a judge issued a temporary restraining order that halted medical aid in dying in New Jersey. Within two weeks, however, an appellate court reversed the decision and stated Glassmans suit did not meet required standards. Glassman plans to appeal until all options are exhausted.
Although opponents to medical aid in dying have tried to end the laws, legal scholar Thaddeus Mason Pope expects legal access to expand in the coming years. He says he anticipates 15 additional states will pass medical aid in dying laws in the next five years.
Youll see it become the norm, not the exception, says Pope, who is a professor of law at the Mitchell Hamline School of Law in Saint Paul and the Director of the Health Law Institute.
Barriers to accesssuch as the waiting period between requestsare likely to be relaxed, Pope says. States are also likely to increase the life expectancy minimum from six to 12 months.
Advocates such as Diaz are eager to see the expansion. He feels his wife passed peacefully and was spared from an imminent and painful death.
She saved herself from an enormous amount of tragic suffering in front of her, Diaz says.
Emilie Le Beau Lucchesi is the author of Ugly Prey: An Innocent Woman and the Death Sentence that Scandalized Jazz Age Chicago and This Is Really War: The Incredible True Story of a Navy Nurse POW in the Occupied Philippines. She has a PhD in communication from the University of Illinois at Chicago and studies health communication, medical history and stigma communication.
Go here to see the original:
Why states are on the fence about a patient's right to die - ABA Journal
- Sun Prairie fences off pond where 2 brothers died after falling through ice - Fox11online.com - January 22nd, 2024 [January 22nd, 2024]
- BBMP to spend 32.5 crore to fence lakes - Times of India - January 22nd, 2024 [January 22nd, 2024]
- Stray Cat Watches Guy Through Hole In Fence Hiding An Adorable Secret - The Dodo - January 22nd, 2024 [January 22nd, 2024]
- Everyone can see the fence but you have the eyes of a hawk if you can spot the cat in ten seconds... - The US Sun - January 22nd, 2024 [January 22nd, 2024]
- Wisconsin city fences off pond following deaths of 2 boys who fell through ice - Fox News - January 22nd, 2024 [January 22nd, 2024]
- Sun Prairie fences off pond where 2 boys died after falling through ice - Ashland Daily Press - January 22nd, 2024 [January 22nd, 2024]
- Will Mass Migration Breach Poland's Famous Border Fence? - The National Interest Online - January 22nd, 2024 [January 22nd, 2024]
- 'The Bear': Ebon Moss-Bachrach On Whether Carmy & Richie Mend Fences In Season 3 Emmys Red Carpet - Yahoo New Zealand News - January 22nd, 2024 [January 22nd, 2024]
- India Plans to Fence Off Myanmar Frontier - The Irrawaddy - January 22nd, 2024 [January 22nd, 2024]
- Migrant pinned to fence and dragged away after trying to speak to reporters at Manston in Kent - Sky News - November 10th, 2022 [November 10th, 2022]
- Balkan Route: Hungary Increasing Fence on Serbian Border Amid Ongoing Violence and Extended Controls, NGOs to Launch a Joint Action to Support... - November 10th, 2022 [November 10th, 2022]
- Parents devastated after autistic child kicked out of school because it doesn't have a fence - Newshub - November 10th, 2022 [November 10th, 2022]
- Fence surrounding US Capitol is expected to come down starting on July 8 - Fox News - July 2nd, 2021 [July 2nd, 2021]
- The Peruvian Pavilion in the 2021 Venice Biennale Seeks to Transform Fences into Tools for Integration - ArchDaily - July 2nd, 2021 [July 2nd, 2021]
- Galloping and Setting Up for Cross-Country Fences: A Conversation - United States Eventing Association - July 2nd, 2021 [July 2nd, 2021]
- On the fence about getting your children vaccinated for COVID? Here are a few reasons to consider it - Providence - July 2nd, 2021 [July 2nd, 2021]
- Fence Supply Inc. Forms Partnership with Fencing Supply Group, a Portfolio Company of The Sterling Group - PRNewswire - July 2nd, 2021 [July 2nd, 2021]
- Why You Need to Turn Around When You See A Purple Fence Post in IL - q985online.com - July 2nd, 2021 [July 2nd, 2021]
- 'The Fence is Never Coming Down,' and Other Things Urban Alchemy Told Us - Knock LA - July 2nd, 2021 [July 2nd, 2021]
- Coffee shop owners forgive teens who graffitied fence, let them paint over it - Yahoo News - July 2nd, 2021 [July 2nd, 2021]
- Is This Why Prince Harry Can't Mend Fences With The Royals - The List - July 2nd, 2021 [July 2nd, 2021]
- Why Tho? Weve been warned about you! Neighbors find theyre the Boo Radleys of the subdivision - OregonLive - July 2nd, 2021 [July 2nd, 2021]
- Bear Spotted At Area Condo Complex Before Climbing Fence - Southwest Dutchess Daily Voice - July 2nd, 2021 [July 2nd, 2021]
- Bear Spotted At Westchester Condo Complex Before Climbing Fence - White Plains Daily Voice - July 2nd, 2021 [July 2nd, 2021]
- Policy regime nudged fence-sitters to be first-time homebuyers: Niranjan Hiranandani - BusinessLine - July 2nd, 2021 [July 2nd, 2021]
- Baseball Mascots: Ranking the MLB Mascots - Through The Fence Baseball - July 2nd, 2021 [July 2nd, 2021]
- Over the Garden Fence: Your garden in the spotlight - Bournemouth Echo - July 2nd, 2021 [July 2nd, 2021]
- Group formed to make fences more wildlife friendly in Cody area - Billings Gazette - February 9th, 2021 [February 9th, 2021]
- Dog abandoned, left tied to fence in Escondido park - 10News - February 9th, 2021 [February 9th, 2021]
- Unusual history behind the fences on South London estates dating back to the war - My London - February 9th, 2021 [February 9th, 2021]
- Bill Press: Tear down this fence! | TheHill - The Hill - February 9th, 2021 [February 9th, 2021]
- DHHL removes campers, installs fence in Kalawahine on Oahu - KHON2 - February 9th, 2021 [February 9th, 2021]
- Driver in custody after plowing through fence, ending pursuit with lengthy standoff in Woodland Hills - KTLA Los Angeles - February 9th, 2021 [February 9th, 2021]
- Reopening gripes, fence frustrations and a wage freeze | HeraldNet.com - The Daily Herald - February 9th, 2021 [February 9th, 2021]
- Yeh, nah, maybe. When it comes to accepting the COVID vaccine, it's Australia's fence-sitters we should pay attention to - The Conversation AU - February 9th, 2021 [February 9th, 2021]
- New Plymouth woman goes on the fence offensive - Stuff.co.nz - February 9th, 2021 [February 9th, 2021]
- LFR battles shed fire that spread to fence, threatened 2 homes in East Lubbock Sunday - KLBK | KAMC | EverythingLubbock.com - February 9th, 2021 [February 9th, 2021]
- [UPDATED] Driver Hits Multiple Cars and a Fence in Early Morning Crash, Says Fortuna PD Redheaded Blackbelt - Redheaded Blackbelt - February 9th, 2021 [February 9th, 2021]
- Audio: Missouri fence laws topic of in-person program on February 23 and March 8, 2021 - kttn - February 9th, 2021 [February 9th, 2021]
- There Are Ways To Protect The Capitol Without A Fence - Yahoo News - February 9th, 2021 [February 9th, 2021]
- On The Fence About COVID Vaccines? These Teens Want To Talk To You - Colorado Public Radio - February 9th, 2021 [February 9th, 2021]
- Across the Fence: Salt On Our Tongues - The Suburban Times - February 9th, 2021 [February 9th, 2021]
- New London woman drives through yards and fences, crashes into garage after leaving car wash in Willmar - West Central Tribune - February 4th, 2021 [February 4th, 2021]
- Everyday Ethics: Fences and neighbors [Opinion] - Reading Eagle - February 4th, 2021 [February 4th, 2021]
- Independence amends ordinance on fences, hedges and walls - cleveland.com - February 4th, 2021 [February 4th, 2021]
- Proposal to build permanent fence around the Capitol meets resistance - CNN - February 4th, 2021 [February 4th, 2021]
- Rep. Bob Gibbs gives thumbs up to border fence, thumbs down to Capitol Hill security fence - cleveland.com - February 4th, 2021 [February 4th, 2021]
- Watch: More Barbed Wire Fences, Spikes On Roads At Singhu Protest Site - NDTV - February 4th, 2021 [February 4th, 2021]
- Rep. Budd tells Congress to tear down its fence - Washington Times - February 4th, 2021 [February 4th, 2021]
- Section Of Fence At Silverdale Detention Center Found To Have Been Cut; All Inmates Accounted For - The Chattanoogan - February 4th, 2021 [February 4th, 2021]
- Types of Fences - The Home Depot - January 30th, 2021 [January 30th, 2021]
- Fences 3.09 for Windows - Download - January 30th, 2021 [January 30th, 2021]
- Wood Fence Panels - Wood Fencing - The Home Depot - January 30th, 2021 [January 30th, 2021]
- McCarthy Tries to Mend Fences With Trump - The Wall Street Journal - January 30th, 2021 [January 30th, 2021]
- Casual Friday: New Nez Perce County sheriff looks to mend fences - Lewiston Morning Tribune - January 30th, 2021 [January 30th, 2021]
- US Capitol surrounded by fence, troops as threats continue - NEWS10 ABC - January 30th, 2021 [January 30th, 2021]
- Take a pair, leave a pair: The Mitten Fence at Buffalos Peoples Park is helping keep the Queen City warm - WIVB.com - News 4 - January 30th, 2021 [January 30th, 2021]
- Contract approved to fence Oceanside railroad tracks - The San Diego Union-Tribune - January 30th, 2021 [January 30th, 2021]
- PHOTOS: New initiative helping Wyoming landowners fix fences to protect wildlife - Oil City News - January 15th, 2021 [January 15th, 2021]
- Fences and neighbors - The River Reporter - January 15th, 2021 [January 15th, 2021]
- Emma Thompson to Hurl You Over the Fence as Miss Trunchbull in Netflixs Musical Matilda - Vulture - January 15th, 2021 [January 15th, 2021]
- Mitten fence helping hundreds in Buffalo stay warm this winter - WKBW-TV - January 15th, 2021 [January 15th, 2021]
- The perfect symbol of the Trump years - CNN - January 15th, 2021 [January 15th, 2021]
- Building a Fence: Washington and the Magnificent Seven - UW Dawg Pound - January 15th, 2021 [January 15th, 2021]
- Mining Weekly BHP puts up wind fence in WA - Creamer Media's Mining Weekly - January 15th, 2021 [January 15th, 2021]
- Woman dies after driving through fence onto I-15 in Beaver - KSL.com - January 15th, 2021 [January 15th, 2021]
- Maserati driver smashes through fences, tree and shed - KOIN.com - December 21st, 2020 [December 21st, 2020]
- The story behind the painted fences & sheds in one Lake Grove neighborhood - GreaterMoriches - December 21st, 2020 [December 21st, 2020]
- On the fence: Messages of hope on display in downtown Nashua - The Union Leader - December 21st, 2020 [December 21st, 2020]
- US wants India to get off the fence over China. But forgets Cuban crisis lesson - ThePrint - December 21st, 2020 [December 21st, 2020]
- Across the Fence: and Peace on Earth - The Suburban Times - December 21st, 2020 [December 21st, 2020]
- City fixes Cameron Heights fence after deaths of several deer and years of complaints - CBC.ca - December 21st, 2020 [December 21st, 2020]
- See Austin Condo Tower Construction Up Close With 'Beyond the Fence' Episode 2 - TOWERS Austin - December 21st, 2020 [December 21st, 2020]
- Vaccine hesitancy and COVID-19: How many will stay on the fence? - Windsor Star - December 21st, 2020 [December 21st, 2020]
- Israeli forces carry out a land incursion and threaten to remove Palestinian farmers' crops - occupied Palestinian territory - ReliefWeb - December 21st, 2020 [December 21st, 2020]
- Tributes paid to 'lovely' and 'kind' dad who died after his car crashed into a fence - Manchester Evening News - December 21st, 2020 [December 21st, 2020]
- Straddlin' the Fence: Why should I vote? - Idaho Press-Tribune - October 30th, 2020 [October 30th, 2020]
- Visalia orders church to remove Black Lives Matter signs from 'prayer fence,' citing ordinance - Visalia Times-Delta and Tulare Advance-Register - October 30th, 2020 [October 30th, 2020]
- Fence to be installed around monuments in A'ville - Sand Mountain Reporter - October 30th, 2020 [October 30th, 2020]
- Gov. Ron DeSantis swings for the fences with early voting message to Florida Republicans - Florida Politics - October 23rd, 2020 [October 23rd, 2020]