LOS ANGELES (KUSI) Los Angeles County health officials acted arbitrarily and without a proper risk-benefit analysis when they banned outdoor dining as a coronavirus-control measure, a judge ruled Tuesday, but the decision wont immediately restore in-person dining.
Following a hearing that lasted more than an hour, Los Angeles Superior Court Judge James Chalfant upheld an earlier tentative ruling, in which he found that the county failed to perform the required risk-benefit analysis before enacting the ban.
By failing to weigh the benefits of an outdoor dining restriction against its costs, the county acted arbitrarily and its decision lacks a rational relationship to a legitimate end, Chalfant wrote in his ruling, which stemmed from lawsuits filed by the California Restaurant Association and the owner of the downtown Engine Co. No. 28 restaurant, attorney Mark Geragos.
The balance of harms works in petitioners favor until such time as the county concludes after proper risk-benefit analysis that restaurants must be closed to protect the healthcare system, Chalfant wrote.
Although Chalfant had already penned the 53-page tentative ruling and upheld it during the hearing, attorneys for the California Restaurant Association are expected to craft a shorter document that Chalfant will sign, making the order official.
The judge noted in his ruling that the county did show surging COVID- 19 cases are burdening the health care system and action is necessary. He also said the county has presented generalized evidence of transmission risk from outdoor dining.
But he said the countys assertion that the virus can be spread on restaurant patios by patrons spending extended periods of time without masks only weakly supports the closure of outdoor restaurant dining, because it ignores the outdoor nature of the activity, which the CDC (U.S. Centers for Disease Control and Prevention) says carries only a moderate risk, and less with mitigations.
Diners eat lunch outside at Settebello Pizzeria Napoletana on Tuesday, Dec. 1, 2020, in Pasadena, Calif. Pasadena has become an island in the center of the nations most populous county, where a surge of COVID-19 cases last week led to a three-week end to outdoor dining and Californias first stay-home order since the pandemic began to spread across the state in March. The decision by Pasadena health authorities to buck Los Angeles County has been a relief to restaurateurs who have struggled to stay afloat amid closures, ever-changing rules and attempts to keep workers on the job and money in the till. (AP Photo/Marcio Jose Sanchez)
While siding with the restaurant industry, Chalfant noted that due to the states regional stay-at-home order that took effect Sunday night and which also includes a ban on in-person dining outdoor restaurant dining in the county cannot open at this time.
Chalfant instead enjoined the county from imposing its dining ban beyond the original three-week time period, which ends Dec. 16. The states order at a minimum will be in place until Dec. 27. But Chalfant said the county which is obliged to adhere to the states order can only extend the restriction beyond that after conducting an appropriate risk-benefit analysis.
Chalfant wrote that he cant dictate what that analysis should entail, but suggested that the county could be expected to consider the economic cost of closing 30,000 restaurants, the impact to restaurant owners and their employees and the psychological and emotional cost to a public tired of the pandemic and seeking some form of employment in their lives.
Chalfant said during the hearing he was surprised that no study has been done at any government level since the outbreak began about the alleged effects of outdoor dining on the spread of the coronavirus. He also said the average healthy person is not severely at risk of dying of the virus.
The county Department of Public Health imposed the ban on Nov. 25, citing surging COVID-19 cases and hospitalizations. The county Board of Supervisors debated the issue on Nov. 24, but voted 3-2 to support the ban, arguing that restaurant patrons spend extended periods of time in close proximity and without wearing masks.
The California Restaurant Association and Geragos, however, challenged the ban in court.
The recent order with no stated scientific basis from L.A. County singles out a specific industry and could jeopardize thousands of jobs, Jot Condie, president/CEO of the California Restaurant Association, said in a statement announcing the lawsuit. There are thousands of restaurants and many thousands more employees who could be out on the street right before the holiday season.
Geragos told Chalfant he will bring another lawsuit, this time challenging the state order.
Prior to the ban on outdoor dining being imposed, the county had already restricted restaurant patios to 50% of capacity.
The ban on in-person dining has been met with an outcry from restaurant owners across the county, with some saying they spent thousands of dollars to establish safe outdoor dining spaces under the previous county guidelines, only to be forced to shut down on Nov. 25 without justification.
Opponents of the ban have said it would cause tens of thousands of restaurant workers to lose their jobs. There are more than 30,000 restaurants in Los Angeles County.
Attorney Amnon Z. Siegel, on behalf of the county, told the judge that with the uptick in coronavirus cases, we are in scary new territory and the number of ICU hospital beds continues to dwindle. He said the county by law was not required to do a risk-benefit analysis.
Chalfant said he recognizes the seriousness of the hospital bed problem, but insisted there is no concrete evidence that banning outdoor dining will help.
The judge, who acknowledged he has had struggled to keep his own personal beliefs out of the discussion, also said departments within the county other than the Department of Public Health should be involved in fighting the pandemic. He said he does not believe officials when they say there are manpower shortages in dealing with the problem, and he also predicted that the states stay-at-home order will not work.
People are not going to stay home, Chalfant said.
Read more:
Judge rules LA County acted without proper 'risk-benefit' analysis in banning patio dining - - KUSI
- The Best Ottomans For Patio of 2024 - The Jerusalem Post - February 7th, 2024 [February 7th, 2024]
- Burr Ridge 3-bedroom home with Bluestone patio: $1.8M - Chicago Tribune - February 7th, 2024 [February 7th, 2024]
- The Surprising Kitchen Ingredient That Can Kill Patio Moss - House Beautiful - February 7th, 2024 [February 7th, 2024]
- Nashville's 'largest rooftop patio' getting year-round canopy - Tennessean - February 7th, 2024 [February 7th, 2024]
- Stubborn patio moss will 'disappear and not come back' with 29p miracle ingredient - The Mirror - February 7th, 2024 [February 7th, 2024]
- For The Home | Get inspired at PlantCon and create a garden on your balcony or patio! - KPRC Click2Houston - February 7th, 2024 [February 7th, 2024]
- Patio moss will disappear and not come back with 29p effective item paving expert loves - Express - February 7th, 2024 [February 7th, 2024]
- Woman shares vinegar hack to get rid of moss on patio and driveway - Leicestershire Live - February 7th, 2024 [February 7th, 2024]
- 'Simplest' method to prevent patio weeds from growing stops them 'settling between slabs' - Express - February 7th, 2024 [February 7th, 2024]
- NOTL Coun. Gary Burroughs proposes to limit patios - Niagara This Week - February 7th, 2024 [February 7th, 2024]
- 5 Ways to Revive a Patio After Winter Small Tricks Landscape Designers Rely On - LivingEtc - February 7th, 2024 [February 7th, 2024]
- Best way to easily remove moss from patio or driveways in 20 minutes with home staple - Express - February 7th, 2024 [February 7th, 2024]
- 8 Best Garden Stools of 2024 - The Jerusalem Post - February 7th, 2024 [February 7th, 2024]
- 17 Covered and Heated Patios Perfect for Cold, Rainy Weather in Seattle - EverOut - January 22nd, 2024 [January 22nd, 2024]
- 7 dog-friendly heated patios in Huntsville to check out - Hville Blast - January 22nd, 2024 [January 22nd, 2024]
- Ignoring This Patio Problem Could Knock Off 20% Of Your Home's Value - House Digest - January 22nd, 2024 [January 22nd, 2024]
- 8 Best Patio Loveseats Review - The Jerusalem Post - January 22nd, 2024 [January 22nd, 2024]
- Springfield restaurants offer outdoor dining during winter with heated patios - Standard Online - January 22nd, 2024 [January 22nd, 2024]
- Paving expert shares 27p solution to kill weeds and moss and prevent them growing back - Express - January 22nd, 2024 [January 22nd, 2024]
- Patios on Banff Avenue to resume this year despite Parks Canada's opposition - Calgary Herald - January 22nd, 2024 [January 22nd, 2024]
- Were not in this together: Outdoor patios shuttered, warned over public health restrictions - Toronto Star - January 25th, 2022 [January 25th, 2022]
- After nearly 2 years of expanded outdoor patios, Fort Collins mulls making them permanent - Coloradoan - January 25th, 2022 [January 25th, 2022]
- 15 Heated patios for those cooler days in Tucson - Tucson Foodie - January 25th, 2022 [January 25th, 2022]
- Patios and drive-in movies carry Gananoque through another pandemic winter - CBC.ca - January 25th, 2022 [January 25th, 2022]
- This three-story home in Oak Cliff has a rooftop patio - The Dallas Morning News - January 25th, 2022 [January 25th, 2022]
- These Gorgeous Fire Pit Tables Will Transform Your Outdoor Space Into A Winter Oasis | The Weather Channel - Articles from The Weather Channel |... - January 25th, 2022 [January 25th, 2022]
- Bar Ivy Will Breeze Into Clarendon With a 125-Seat Patio Shaded by Crepe Myrtles - Eater DC - January 25th, 2022 [January 25th, 2022]
- Platinum Patio and Pavers Opens New Location in Barrington IL and Palatine IL - GlobeNewswire - January 25th, 2022 [January 25th, 2022]
- Toronto's New Winter Patio Is Like A Trip To The Alps & You Can Sip Mulled Wine By A Fire - Narcity Canada - January 25th, 2022 [January 25th, 2022]
- This $550K Home Near Ottawa Has A Patio On Every Level & Walls Full Of Windows - Narcity Canada - January 25th, 2022 [January 25th, 2022]
- Wellington Drive live on the patio at beergarden KEZI Calendar - KEZI TV - January 25th, 2022 [January 25th, 2022]
- The New Opalhouse x Jungalow Collection at Target Is Here to Refresh Your Home For 2022 - POPSUGAR - January 25th, 2022 [January 25th, 2022]
- Wisdom and incredible strength: the exhibition showing the lives built by Holocaust survivors - The Guardian - January 25th, 2022 [January 25th, 2022]
- Lampposts Market Size, Forecast, and Top Firms Paradise Garden Lighting, Patio Living Concepts, New England Arbors, Gama Sonic, iGuzzini The Oxford... - January 25th, 2022 [January 25th, 2022]
- Chicago's best restaurants with heated patios - Eater Chicago - January 25th, 2022 [January 25th, 2022]
- WATCH: Man fights off bear to save dachshunds - BRProud.com - January 25th, 2022 [January 25th, 2022]
- Stay Warm At These Heated Nashville Restaurant Patios - StyleBlueprint - February 20th, 2021 [February 20th, 2021]
- Keeping Toronto closed now may prevent another lockdown right before patios open, Tory says - CP24 Toronto's Breaking News - February 20th, 2021 [February 20th, 2021]
- Extending Toronto's lockdown could prevent another one before patios reopen: Tory | Dished - Daily Hive - February 20th, 2021 [February 20th, 2021]
- Popular patio pop-ups expanding this summer - Winnipeg Free Press - February 20th, 2021 [February 20th, 2021]
- City of Vancouver to open summer patio applications from food and beverage establishments on March 1 - Straight.com - February 20th, 2021 [February 20th, 2021]
- The Lansing poll winner of Michigans Best Outdoor Dining is a deck over the Looking Glass River - MLive.com - February 20th, 2021 [February 20th, 2021]
- Where to Day Drink in Houston 18 Restaurants and Bars That Can Make Any Afternoon a Celebration - PaperCity Magazine - February 20th, 2021 [February 20th, 2021]
- New Rise Woodfire restaurant stokes the ovens at San Mateo train station - East Bay Times - February 20th, 2021 [February 20th, 2021]
- Global Outdoor Patio Umbrella Market Share, Business Opportunities, Drivers, Challenges and Forecast to 2027 | Reportspedia The Bisouv Network - The... - February 20th, 2021 [February 20th, 2021]
- Comprehensive Report on Patio Awnings Market 2021 | Trends, Growth Demand, Opportunities & Forecast To 2027 |Erhardt, AandA International, Eide... - February 20th, 2021 [February 20th, 2021]
- College Hill's Brink Brewing Co. to Celebrate Fourth Anniversary with Heated Patio Party - Cincinnati CityBeat - February 17th, 2021 [February 17th, 2021]
- See a hidden University Park home lauded in the 1940s for its spacious front-yard patio - The Dallas Morning News - February 17th, 2021 [February 17th, 2021]
- Check Out This New Addition at Downtown Grand Junction Restaurant - kool1079.com - February 17th, 2021 [February 17th, 2021]
- Create Your New Outdoor Living Space with Precision Patio Covers - ThurstonTalk - February 17th, 2021 [February 17th, 2021]
- Uptick in Backyard Hangouts? Pick up This Discounted Patio Heater - gearpatrol.com - February 17th, 2021 [February 17th, 2021]
- Where to Dine Outside in Vancouver - Eater Portland - February 17th, 2021 [February 17th, 2021]
- Impact Of Covid 19 On Online Outdoor Patio Umbrella Industry 2020 Market Challenges, Business Overview And Forecast Research Study 2026 NeighborWebSJ... - February 17th, 2021 [February 17th, 2021]
- Glory Days Grill Fights the COVID-19 Battle on Multiple Fronts - FSR magazine - February 17th, 2021 [February 17th, 2021]
- Outdoor Living Products Market Competitive Outlook and Economic Forecasting | Ace Hardware, Century Furniture LLC., Forever Patio., DEDON INC KSU |... - February 17th, 2021 [February 17th, 2021]
- Outdoor Patio Heaters Market 2020 |Global Industry Analysis By Trends, Size, Share, Company Overview, Growth And Forecast By 2027| Latest Research... - February 17th, 2021 [February 17th, 2021]
- Winter storm deals Portland area restaurants yet another blow - OregonLive - February 17th, 2021 [February 17th, 2021]
- Patio Heaters and Barbecue Accessories Market Size by Top Key Players, SWOT Analysis, Business Overview, Forecast 2027 The Bisouv Network - The... - February 17th, 2021 [February 17th, 2021]
- The Best To-Go Dishes (and Drinks!) at the Newest Restaurants in Texas - Texas Monthly - February 17th, 2021 [February 17th, 2021]
- The Washington Post gives shout out to Birmingham's The Essential + Bandit Patisserie - Bham Now - February 17th, 2021 [February 17th, 2021]
- Dress up a garden path or patio with gravel or paving stones: Should you splurge on bluestone? - OregonLive - February 9th, 2021 [February 9th, 2021]
- Outdoor Patio Pick of the Week: The Penmar Venice - L.A. Weekly - February 9th, 2021 [February 9th, 2021]
- Patio dining to roll out on Toronto sidewalks, streets in May if public health protocols allow - CTV Toronto - February 9th, 2021 [February 9th, 2021]
- What $1 Million Buys You in California - The New York Times - February 9th, 2021 [February 9th, 2021]
- The Best Outdoor Heater to Warm Up the Patio - BobVila.com - February 9th, 2021 [February 9th, 2021]
- Kitchener to waive patio fees, continue offering free downtown parking - CTV Toronto - February 9th, 2021 [February 9th, 2021]
- Mum and daughter, 9, forced to dig own graves before partner buried them under patio - Mirror.co.uk - February 9th, 2021 [February 9th, 2021]
- Mum & daughter, 9, forced to dig their own graves before being buried under patio by partner - The Sun - February 9th, 2021 [February 9th, 2021]
- Where to Dine Out for Valentines Day 2020 in Portland - Eater Portland - February 9th, 2021 [February 9th, 2021]
- Safety Net Market Consumption Analysis, Business Overview and Upcoming Trends|Abba Patio, Kidkusion, JFN, Asoner, Changsha Wuxing, etc KSU | The... - February 9th, 2021 [February 9th, 2021]
- Prep your patio for spring with 48-feet of string lighting, now $24 (Save 43%) - 9to5Toys - February 9th, 2021 [February 9th, 2021]
- The porcelain floors and marbled patio of Midleton's 415k Redwood - Irish Examiner - February 9th, 2021 [February 9th, 2021]
- The Inside Outside Guys: That sinking feeling concrete slabs, porches and patios - The Detroit News - January 15th, 2021 [January 15th, 2021]
- Playoffs on the Patios a hit on Chippewa during Bills playoff win - WGRZ.com - January 15th, 2021 [January 15th, 2021]
- Indoor dining is off the table until Feb. 1, but patios are flourishing, even in a Michigan winter - WSYM-TV - January 15th, 2021 [January 15th, 2021]
- Map: Here are the bars and restaurants with heated patio seating in SLC - KSL.com - January 15th, 2021 [January 15th, 2021]
- Playoffs on the Patio should continue for next Bills Playoff Game - WIVB.com - News 4 - January 15th, 2021 [January 15th, 2021]
- Pandemic pricing? Cost of a patio heater quadrupled on Amazon - CBS News - January 15th, 2021 [January 15th, 2021]
- Patio lighting ideas: 16 ways to illuminate your plot with pendants, fairy lights, stakes and more - Yahoo Lifestyle UK - January 15th, 2021 [January 15th, 2021]
- Playoffs on the Patios sells out in 8 Hours - Buffalo Rising - January 15th, 2021 [January 15th, 2021]