One would expect, when hiring a plumber, that the plumber will not cause a fire when using a blowtorch and solder. If a fire breaks out shortly after the plumber used a blowtorch and solder, in the vicinity of his/her work area, one might assume that the fire was caused by the plumbers work. However, this assumption alone will not suffice to establish negligence.
In Metropolitan Toronto Condominium Corporation No. 1100 v. A. & G. Shanks Plumbing & Heating Limited (MTCC 1100),[i] a fire destroyed a historic mansion, which was part of a condominium development. The fire was detected shortly after a plumber employed by A. & G. Shanks Plumbing & Heating Limited (Shanks) had repaired a leaking pipe in the basement ceiling, using a blowtorch and solder. The plumber finished his work at around 2:45 p.m., conducted a fire watch until 3:15 p.m., and then left at 3:20 p.m. Half an hour later, at 3:51 p.m., a 9-1-1 call was made reporting a fire at the mansion. It was determined that the fire originated in the ceiling, near the location of the plumbers work. The condominium corporation (MTCC 1100) sued Shanks in negligence for close to $5.5 million in damages.
MTCC 1100 adduced expert evidence that the fire was caused by the flame of the plumbers torch coming into contact with combustible materials in the work area a fairly confined space between the basement ceiling and the floor above, where the leaking pipe was located. The trial judge had some difficulty with this expert evidence. One of MTCC 1100s experts opined that the combustible materials located above the work area must have been ignited by an open flame directed upwards. However, the parties had admitted, in an agreed statement of facts, that the plumber pointed his blowtorch downwards towards the ground when he was doing the soldering work. Hence, the factual foundation for the expert opinion (an upward open flame) was contradicted by the evidence (a downward open flame). MTCC 1100 unsuccessfully argued that there was no other explanation for the fire. The trial judge wrote:
While the evidence is somewhat problematic, in that [the plumber] was the only one working in the immediate vicinity of the location where the fire originated, and in that soon after his work a fire started, there was no evidence that anything he did caused the fire.[ii]
The trial judge also took issue with the lack of evidence on the applicable standard of care. At the commencement of trial, MTCC 1100s counsel stated that no expert on a plumbers standard of care would give evidence as it was obvious that [the plumbers conduct] fell below the necessary standard of care.[iii] MTCC 1100 argued that the plumbers conduct was egregious, such that expert evidence on the standard of care was not necessary. MTCC 1100 relied on 495793 Ontario Ltd. (Central Auto Parts) v. Barclay,[iv] in which the Court of Appeal discussed two exceptions to the general rule that it is not possible to determine professional negligence without the benefit of expert evidence:[v]
The trial judge disagreed that the plumbers conduct was egregious. The plumber testified at trial about the numerous precautions he had taken while doing his work. He also testified that he pointed the flame of the blowtorch in a downward direction and away from the wood structures above him. The trial judge found his testimony credible.
MTCC 1100 suggested that the plumber could have used a rigid fire shield or a heat barrier spray. The difficulty, however, is that no expert testified that the plumber should indeed have taken such precautions. MTCC 1100 tendered some evidence on the standard of care by reference to the National Fire Code of Canada 2005 and the Fire Code, O. Reg. 213/07. The trial judge refused to consider the National Fire Code of Canada 2005, as there was no expert evidence that it formed part of the standard of care applicable to plumbers in Ontario in 2009. As for the Fire Code, O. Reg. 213/07, it did not include soldering as part of its Hot Works regulations at the time of the fire, and was therefore inapplicable. The trial judge held:
There was a debate not only as to what regulatory standards applied in 2009 but also as to how those standards should have been applied by [the plumber]. In my view it was incumbent upon the plaintiffs to lead expert evidence to establish the appropriate standard of care in order for the court to find that it had been breached. They did not do so and because of this their claims must be dismissed.[vii]
MTCC 1100 appealed from the decision, and argued that the trial judge should have drawn inferences of a breach of the standard of care and of causation based on the circumstantial evidence, namely, that a fire occurred under the plumbers watch, with no alternate explanation for how the fire occurred.[viii] While the Court of Appeal agreed that such inferences could be drawn, it noted that they can also be rebutted by the defendant, including by pointing out to other non-negligent causes of the fire or adducing evidence that supports the exercise of reasonable care. The Court of Appeal held that the trial judge was entitled to conclude that, considering all the direct and circumstantial evidence, [MTCC 1100] had failed to discharge their burden of proving a breach of the standard of care.[ix]
Whether a plumber should use a rigid fire shield or a heat barrier spray is technical in nature and not within the knowledge of the ordinary person. Thus, this called for expert evidence. Also, it does not appear that the conduct of the plumber was egregious in any way. As noted by the Court of Appeal in Barclay: Dictionary definitions of egregious include synonyms such as shocking, appalling, terrible, awful, horrendous, frightful, atrocious, abominable, abhorrent, and outrageous.[x] Absent any negligent conduct that clearly falls within that definition, a plaintiff should consider adducing expert opinion on the applicable standard of care of a tradesperson or professional. Otherwise, the Court may not be able to determine whether the conduct was negligent under the circumstances.
See original here:
Appeal Dismissed: There Was No Other Explanation for the Fire, but There Was Also No Expert Evidence - Lexology
- Melbourne-Based Zebra Plumbing Is the Go-To Plumber for ... - Benzinga - May 7th, 2023 [May 7th, 2023]
- Sen. Kane: The plumber's perspective on Pennsylvania's budget - Broad + Liberty - May 7th, 2023 [May 7th, 2023]
- Don't Wait for a 'Plumber' to Fix the Financial System - RealMoney - May 7th, 2023 [May 7th, 2023]
- 'White House Plumbers' puts a laugh-out-loud spin on the Watergate ... - NPR - May 7th, 2023 [May 7th, 2023]
- Mario: Is Our Favorite Italian Plumber the Next Big Time Movie ... - MovieWeb - May 7th, 2023 [May 7th, 2023]
- From Plumbers to Electricians, the U.S. is Gasping for Skilled Workers - Atalayar - May 7th, 2023 [May 7th, 2023]
- Veep and White House Plumbers Showrunner David Mandel Fears the WGA Strike Will Be Long and Bloody - Yahoo Entertainment - May 7th, 2023 [May 7th, 2023]
- 'White House Plumbers,' 'Silo' Debut: What's Premiering This Week ... - Next TV - May 7th, 2023 [May 7th, 2023]
- Southampton man launches 200k claim against NHS for loss of sex life - Southern Daily Echo - May 7th, 2023 [May 7th, 2023]
- Emmy Experts Typing: Will any late release break through in the chaotic limited categories? - Gold Derby - May 7th, 2023 [May 7th, 2023]
- The 10 Best Plumbers Near Me | Free Plumbing Reviews Near Me | Angi - April 13th, 2023 [April 13th, 2023]
- This is it: Dads brush with death during Geelong Ring Road disaster - Geelong Advertiser - April 13th, 2023 [April 13th, 2023]
- Its Almost Like an Illusion- Mario Creator Shigeru Miyamoto Reveals the Ideology That Keeps Nintendos Legendary Plumber Welcoming to All Generations -... - April 13th, 2023 [April 13th, 2023]
- Its the Dynamic of This Guy- The Super Mario Bros. Movie Star Seth Rogen Reasons on the Choice of Donkey Kongs Voice - EssentiallySports - April 13th, 2023 [April 13th, 2023]
- How to Hire a Plumber: Qualifications and Costs Forbes Home - March 24th, 2023 [March 24th, 2023]
- What does a plumber do? - CareerExplorer - March 24th, 2023 [March 24th, 2023]
- Plumber Near Me: A Guide to Hiring a Plumber for Your Home - Bob Vila - March 24th, 2023 [March 24th, 2023]
- Hunt quashes plumber claims insisting he is at SuperSport United to deliver and not for financial gains - Goal.com - January 26th, 2023 [January 26th, 2023]
- Kind-hearted plumber gives family 170 in fuel and food after seeing their 'starving poverty' - Yahoo New Zealand News - January 25th, 2022 [January 25th, 2022]
- Plumber gives family 170 of food and fuel to get through to pay day - Wales Online - January 25th, 2022 [January 25th, 2022]
- I saved $500 on a plumber by using three common household products to make the sink drain faster... - The US Sun - January 25th, 2022 [January 25th, 2022]
- Why More Inexperienced Candidates Are Running And Winning - FiveThirtyEight - January 25th, 2022 [January 25th, 2022]
- Burnaby resident fuming as city won't cover cost of sewage damage caused by its system - Burnaby Now - January 25th, 2022 [January 25th, 2022]
- Global Pipe Repair Clamps Market Applications, Types and Future Outlook Report 2021-2027 to Latest Innovations and Major Players are The Plumber's... - January 25th, 2022 [January 25th, 2022]
- Plumbing Devices Market Outlook 2022: Overview, Opportunities, Key Companies and Forecast to 2028 TOTO, Rifeng, Moen, Kohler, Joyou, Jomoo, Jinniu,... - January 25th, 2022 [January 25th, 2022]
- Royal Family: The 22 job vacancies the Queen is looking to fill right now - My London - January 25th, 2022 [January 25th, 2022]
- Get the Lead Out (of Your Home) - Earth911.com - January 25th, 2022 [January 25th, 2022]
- Global Plumbing Supplies & Parts Market 2021 Growth, Trends, Leading Players and Business Insights Forecast to 2027 The Oxford Spokesman - The... - January 25th, 2022 [January 25th, 2022]
- Why Hire Professionals For Plumbing Maintenance: Reasons And Benefits - Seekers Time - February 9th, 2021 [February 9th, 2021]
- What are the Benefits of Hiring a Green Plumber? - Legal Reader - February 9th, 2021 [February 9th, 2021]
- Experts explain how to keep pipes from freezing during frigid weather - KSNT News - February 9th, 2021 [February 9th, 2021]
- Peoria plumber shares tips to prevent pipes from freezing this weekend - CIProud.com - February 9th, 2021 [February 9th, 2021]
- Plumbing Accessories Market Trends, Outlook, Size, Share and Forecast by 2026 | The Plumbers Choice, Oatey, Elmdor, Zurn, Weld-On - The Courier - February 9th, 2021 [February 9th, 2021]
- High Density Plumber Tape Market ? What Factors Will Drive The Market In Upcoming Years And How It Is Going To Impact On Global Industry | (2020-2027)... - February 9th, 2021 [February 9th, 2021]
- Take care now to avoid frozen pipes given the plummeting temps in the forecast - My Ferndale News - February 9th, 2021 [February 9th, 2021]
- Plumbing Parts Market Challenges and Opportunities by Covid-19 Impact Analysis and Future Investments by 2026| HAMAT, ROHL, Dornbracht, Elkay, Native... - February 9th, 2021 [February 9th, 2021]
- 5 Tips in Choosing the Best Plumbing Service for Your Home and Business Needs - LA Progressive - February 9th, 2021 [February 9th, 2021]
- Newswatch 12 - News From Where You Live - Rhinelander Wisconsin WJFW TV-12, WJFWDT 12.1, NBC Affiliate - WJFW-TV - February 9th, 2021 [February 9th, 2021]
- Redundant South Yorkshire hospitality boss retrains as a plumber to beat the pandemic - The Star - January 20th, 2021 [January 20th, 2021]
- Plumber fears his race 'was involved' in client's false accusation over missing 10k - Mirror Online - January 20th, 2021 [January 20th, 2021]
- 'I won't employ anyone that refuses vaccination,' claims plumbing boss - LBC - January 20th, 2021 [January 20th, 2021]
- Plumbing the marvels of 'mRNA' in creating vaccines, therapeutics - Dorchester Reporter - January 20th, 2021 [January 20th, 2021]
- Plumbing Fixtures Market (2021-2026) | Potential growth, attractive valuation make it is a long-term investment | Geberit AG, Jacuzzi, Inc - The... - January 20th, 2021 [January 20th, 2021]
- Plumbing Hardware Market Size By Analysis, Key Vendors, Regions, Type and Application, and Forecasts to 2027 - NeighborWebSJ - January 20th, 2021 [January 20th, 2021]
- What To Always Check When You're In Need Of A Plumber - E/The Environmental Magazine - December 9th, 2020 [December 9th, 2020]
- The Plumber: Plumbing gifts that keep on giving - The Detroit News - December 9th, 2020 [December 9th, 2020]
- Company wins contest for product geared to help plumbers - KOLR - OzarksFirst.com - December 9th, 2020 [December 9th, 2020]
- GE Appliances Announces New Air & Water Solutions to Serve Plumbing and HVAC Industry - ACHR NEWS - December 9th, 2020 [December 9th, 2020]
- Drink-drive plumber had been "having a very difficult year" - Hereford Times - December 9th, 2020 [December 9th, 2020]
- How to Add Plumbing to Your Already Profitable HVAC Business - ACHR NEWS - December 9th, 2020 [December 9th, 2020]
- Get Quality Backed, Prompt, and Cost-Effective Plumbing Services from Boyd Plumbing, Inc. - Press Release - Digital Journal - December 9th, 2020 [December 9th, 2020]
- The 20-year-old trainee plumber from Wythenshawe hoping to sink Spurs in the FA Cup - Manchester Evening News - December 9th, 2020 [December 9th, 2020]
- Plumbers, carpenters, welders, mechanics and aerodrome managers wanted to run Australias Antarctic Program - PerthNow - December 9th, 2020 [December 9th, 2020]
- West Lothian mum fumes after catching her plumber sleeping on the bathroom floor - Edinburgh Live - October 20th, 2020 [October 20th, 2020]
- UFC stars who have other jobs, including McGregor as ex-plumber and Miocic who still works as a firefighter - The Sun - October 20th, 2020 [October 20th, 2020]
- Who installed the sprinkler plumbing? - liherald.com - October 20th, 2020 [October 20th, 2020]
- Joe the plumber? No - The Hindu - October 20th, 2020 [October 20th, 2020]
- Amigo Plumbing and the COVID Comeback - Contractor - October 20th, 2020 [October 20th, 2020]
- Reasons to Hire A Professional Water Heater Plumbing Company - EndZoneScore - October 20th, 2020 [October 20th, 2020]
- Parallel Plumbing And Heating Perhaps Your Best Choice - News Anyway - October 20th, 2020 [October 20th, 2020]
- Superior Plumbing and Heating boasts 40 years of experience - Cut Bank Pioneer Press - October 20th, 2020 [October 20th, 2020]
- Racist actions, attitudes 'nothing new' on construction sites - Construction Dive - October 20th, 2020 [October 20th, 2020]
- "Official Truck of 2020": NKY Plumbing Company Brands Septic Vehicle - The River City News - October 20th, 2020 [October 20th, 2020]
- Plumbers reveal why people shouldn't use this popular cleaning 'hack' - Western Telegraph - October 20th, 2020 [October 20th, 2020]
- Plumbing Market: Good Value & Room to Grow Ahead Seen - The Think Curiouser - October 20th, 2020 [October 20th, 2020]
- Here's How a Local HVAC Company Adapted During the Pandemic - Small Business Trends - October 20th, 2020 [October 20th, 2020]
- Water Saving Plumbing Product Market Trends, Key Players, Overview, Competitive Breakdown and Regional Forecast by 2025 - Eurowire - October 20th, 2020 [October 20th, 2020]
- Plumbing Fixtures Market 2020-2027 Global Industry Development Trends and Analysis - The Think Curiouser - October 20th, 2020 [October 20th, 2020]
- Life Changes: Mission trip to Haiti after earthquake takes Patton Ford from a future in law to plumbing - Northside Sun - October 20th, 2020 [October 20th, 2020]
- This trailblazing plumber seeks gains for other minority women in skilled trades - Las Vegas Sun - October 10th, 2020 [October 10th, 2020]
- 4 Fast Plumbers, Arlington is taking over the plumbing services in Arlington with their broad and professional services - Press Release - Digital... - October 10th, 2020 [October 10th, 2020]
- Fifty-Five Students Awarded Scholarships Through the PHCC Educational Foundation - ACHR NEWS - October 10th, 2020 [October 10th, 2020]
- Do your homework: Household repairs are a recurrent cost and can make us run up huge bills - The Times of India Blog - October 10th, 2020 [October 10th, 2020]
- Super Mario Bros. 35: How to win and be the last surviving plumber - GameCrate - October 10th, 2020 [October 10th, 2020]
- Plumbers frustrated by code change that could take away business - The Topeka Capital-Journal - October 10th, 2020 [October 10th, 2020]
- Plumbing and IOT in South Africa - IT News Africa - October 10th, 2020 [October 10th, 2020]
- Multi Skilled Technician - Joiner/ Plumber job with The Guinness Partnership | 4642979 - Inside Housing - October 10th, 2020 [October 10th, 2020]
- Plumbing, HVAC technician jobs expand with fluctuating workforce - WPTV.com - October 10th, 2020 [October 10th, 2020]
- Luxury Plumbing Fixtures Market Report to 2024 - Trends Insights and Business St - GroundAlerts.com - October 10th, 2020 [October 10th, 2020]
- Gary Pettus Dies at 70; Used Skills To Bless the Lives of People - The New York Times - October 10th, 2020 [October 10th, 2020]